A quiet zone is a railroad grade crossing at which trains are prohibited from sounding their horns in order to decrease the noise level for nearby residential communities. The train horns can be silenced only when other safety measures compensate for the absence of the horns.

The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) train horn rule provides localities nationwide with the opportunity to establish quiet zones. The federal rule pre-empts all applicable state laws. To qualify, communities wishing to establish quiet zones must equip proposed grade crossings with adequate safety measures to overcome the decrease in safety created by silencing the train horns. The additional safety measures must be constructed at the community’s own expense and must meet federal specifications. The federal rule also contains language which for the first time restricts the volume of train horns.

In response to a legislative mandate, FRA has issued a Final Rule on the Use of Locomotive Horns at Highway-Rail Grade Crossings. This final rule, which requires that locomotive horns be sounded as a warning to highway users at public highway-rail crossings, will take effect on June 24, 2005. Until June 24, 2005, the sounding of locomotive horns at public crossings will remain subject to applicable State and local laws. The final rule provides an opportunity, not available until now, for thousands of localities nationwide to mitigate the effects of train horn noise by establishing new "quiet zones." The rule also details actions communities with pre-existing "whistle bans" can take to preserve the quiet they have become accustomed to.

 
Quiet Zone Progress

In 1999 two major railroads acquired the property of former Con Rail Corp.  Norfolk Southern (NS) acquired the tracks bisecting the northern part of Olmsted Falls while CSX Transportation acquired the southern tracks.  NS tracks had approximately 54 trains per day while CSX had only 14.  Based on the proposal that any increase over 8 trains per day would necessitate CSX paying $10,000 for each property with a structure closer than 100 feet from the tracks, CSX paid the City $290,000 as compensation as trains increased from 14 per day to 52.  The City determined to use that money to resolve the overall sound noise in the City.

When the Federal Government (Federal Rail Administration) dragged its feet in publishing the rules and guidelines for the establishment of Quiet Zones which would result in non-horn blowing at our 7 at-grade crossings, 7 communities in our area got together and proposed a pilot Quiet Zone in Brook Park, Berea, Olmsted Falls, Olmsted Township, Middleburg Heights and Strongsville, which was passed by the Ohio Legislature. Those communities paid $5,000 each to have an engineering firm determine what proposed supplemental safety measures may be constructed at crossings in order to permit Quiet Zones to be established.

Olmsted Falls applied for Quiet Zones establishment and submitted proposed engineering documentation. Contracts were awarded to begin the construction of the supplemental safety measures according to the proposed federal rule.   Shortly after the new Ohio law took effect the FRA published their final rule

The rule requires all train engines to blow the horn (whistle) four times in a pattern of 2 long, 1 short, 1 long for a quarter mile before and through the crossing.  Ohio law also requires the same pattern.  Two years later the FRA revised the train horn rule to require that the horn decibel reading should be 110 db.  Thus, the horns have become louder.

Olmsted Falls submitted construction drawings to CSX in March 2006 and got a response in June 2006.  NS received those construction drawings in November 2006.  Some changes in the plans were suggested by the railroads but the final notice of intent to form a Quiet Zone was submitted in June 2006.  Olmsted Falls awarded a construction contract in 2006 and some construction has already occurred, mainly relocation of some driveways close to the crossings.  A diagnostic review team was required by the law and CSX and NS finally came to Olmsted Falls in August 2007.  Mayor Blomquist met with CSX team member regarding the crossings at Sprague, Columbia (South) and West Streets.  Council President Bev Smith met with a NS team member along with a City Engineering staff member. Minor suggestions were made to tweak the grade crossing sites as to visibility of railroad approach signs and elimination of a few street parking spaces.  That work is in progress.

Once the SSMs (supplemental safety measures) or ASMs (alternative safety measures) are completed the notice to Declare the Establishment of the zone is then sent to the following agencies:  Both railroads (NS and CSX), FRA Regional office, Olmsted Falls Police Department, Owner of property for private rail crossing, ODOT (Ohio Department of Transportation), ORDC (Ohio Rail Development Commission, and PUCO (Public Utilities Corporation of Ohio.)

If you would like more information on the use of locomotive horns at public highway-rail grade crossings, use Internet to access the Electronic Code of Federal Regulation, which is less government-ese than the Federal Register.

Contacts

The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
180 E. Broad St. ,
Columbus, OH 43215
Provider (800) 686-PUCO (7826)  /  (800) 686-1570 (TTY-TDD)
Web Address: http://www.puco.ohio.gov/  

Federal Railroad Administration
1120 Vermont Avenue, NW, Stop 35
Washington, DC 20005
(202) 493–6000
Web Address: http://www.fra.dot.gov/us/content/2

CSX Railroad            
Cliff Stayton, Director of Public Affairs and Safety
500 Water Street
Jacksonville , FL. 32202
Phone:  (904) 366-5049
Fax:  (904) 359-1899
Email:  Cliff_Stayton@CSX.com

Norfolk Southern Railroad
Bill Harris
Vice Pres. Public Affairs, Ohio
Phone:  (614) 438-6910 ( Columbus Office)

Ohio Rail Development Commission
Susan Kirkland, Rail Safety Manager
50 W. Broad Street, Suite 1510
Columbus , Ohio 53215
Phone:  (614) 644-0306
Fax:  (614) 728-4520
Website: www.dot.state.OH.US\Ohiorail

Ohio Department of Transportation
980 W. Broad Street
Columbus, OH 43223
Local Contact: (216) 581-2100 / (866) 737-8112
Web Address: http://www.dot.state.oh.us/

U.S. Congressman Dennis J. Kucinich, Ohio’s 10th Congressional District

Lakewood Office
14400 Detroit Avenue
Lakewood, Ohio 44107
Phone (216) 228-8850
Fax (216) 228-6465

Washington Office
2445 Rayburn HOB
Washington, DC 20515
Phone (202) 225-5871
Fax (202) 225-5745

Ohio State Representative Thomas Patton
77 S. High St
13th Floor
Columbus, OH 43215-6111
Telephone: (614) 466-4895
Fax: (614) 719-6957
Email Address: district18@ohr.state.oh.us

Ohio Senator Robert F. Spada  24th District
Statehouse
Columbus , Ohio 43215
Phone: (614) 466-8056
Fax:  (614) 995-1712
Home phone in Parma:  (440) 888-2051
Email:  rspada@mailr.sen.state.oh.us

U.S. Senator George Voinovich
Phone:  (202) 224-3353
Fax:  (216) 522-7097

U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown
Phone: (202) 224-2315
Fax:  (202) 228-6321

Materials
Recent News

Summary of Major Changes in the Amended Train Horn Final Rule

Locomotive Horn Sounding

  • The compliance date of the time-based locomotive horn sounding requirements has been extended to December 15, 2006.(Please refer to section 222.21(b) for more information.)
  • The locomotive horn must be sounded in a time-based manner at private a pedestrian crossings, if State law requires locomotive horn sounding at these crossings. (Please refer to sections 222.25 and 222.27 for more information.)
  • A “good faith” exception has been added to the 20-second maximum locomotive horn sounding requirement for locomotive engineers who are unable to precisely estimate their time of arrival at an upcoming grade crossing. (Please refer to section 222.21(b) for more information.)
  • An exception to the 15-second minimum locomotive horn sounding requirement has been added to the final rule for trains that resume movement after having been stopped in close proximity to a public highway-rail grade crossing. (Please refer to section 222.21(d) for more information.)

Locomotive Audible Warning Devices

  • Locomotive audible warning devices (other than the locomotive horn) must be sounded in a time-based manner at public, private and pedestrian crossings, if State law requires the sounding of locomotive audible warning devices at these crossings. (Please refer to sections 222.21(e), 222.25, and 222.27 for more information.)

Quiet Zone Notification Requirements

  • The public authority must provide a Notice of Intent before submitting an application for FRA approval of a quiet zone. (Please refer to section 222.39(b) for more information.)
  • Pre-Rule Quiet Zones and Pre-Rule Partial Quiet Zones: The public authority must submit a Notice of Intent by February 24, 2008 and a detailed plan for quiet zone improvements by June 24, 2008, in order to prevent the resumption of locomotive horn sounding on June 24, 2008. (Please refer to section 222.41(c)for more information.)

Locomotive Horn Sound Level Requirements

  • Locomotives used in rapid transit operations on the general railroad system are exempt from the locomotive horn sound level and testing requirements contained in section 229.129. (Please refer to section 229.129(d) for more information.)
  • The compliance deadline for sound level testing of new locomotives has been extended to September 18, 2006. (Please refer to section 229.129(b) for more information.)
  • The test site parameters for locomotive horn sound level testing have been revised. (Please refer to section 229.129(c)(5) for more information.)
  • The requirement to record air flow measurements taken during locomotive horn sound level testing has been removed. (Please refer to section 229.129(c)(10) for more information.)
  • The final rule has been revised to address sound level testing of replacement locomotive horns. (Please refer to section 229.129(b)(4) for more information.)
Recent News